New Listings Lake Toxaway Homes & Land

MLS Number 1003251

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 6
• Acreage 3.32

An extraordinary and uniquely distinct opportunity to own three exceptional properties within the prestigious Lake Toxaway Estates. Together, these offerings totaling 3.32 acres total create an unparalleled legacy estate with expansive lakefront, multiple homesites, and outstanding amenities in one of Western North Carolina's most coveted mountain communities. The centerpiece, 1957 Cold Mountain Road, is a remarkable waterfront residence designed for both grand entertaining and relaxed mountain living. The home features 4 bedrooms and 5 & 1/2 baths; highlighted by a dramatic great room with a massive stone fireplace, soaring beamed cathedral ceilings, and an impressive wall of windows that captures breathtaking lake views. A chef's kitchen is equipped with Viking ovens and range, dual dishwashers, and a large center island ideal for gathering. The lower-level family room offers a one-of-a-kind pizza oven, creating the perfect setting for casual entertaining. Additional features include a sauna, elevator, whole-home generator, circular drive, expansive landscaping, and generous covered porches designed to embrace the natural beauty of the surroundings. The property also includes two boathouses with docks and a paved cart path leading directly from the home to one of the boathouses. Ideally positioned across the lake from the Marina, Country Club, and Golf Course, the setting combines privacy with exceptional convenience. Also included is 1923 Cold Mountain Road, consisting of 2 1/2; lots totaling 1.278 acres with the flexibility to subdivide. This exceptional lakefront parcel features a paved drive, boathouse, and docks, offering tremendous potential for an additional residence, guest retreat, or future investment opportunity. Completing the offering is Lot 50N, a 1.37-acre parcel located across Cold Mountain Road from the other properties. Easily developable or marketable as a separate homesite, this parcel adds even greater flexibility and long-term value to this rare multi-property offering. This is a truly extraordinary chance to create a private family compound, investment portfolio, or legacy estate in the heart of Lake Toxaway.

Listed by Kenneth McCall of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 1003315

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 6
• Acreage 1.06

Completed in 2022 and nestled along the shores of Lake Toxaway, this custom-designed lakefront residence blends refined mountain-modern architecture with exceptional craftsmanship and luxurious amenities. Designed to maximize breathtaking water views and seamless indoor-outdoor living, the home features expansive walls of glass, cathedral ceilings with exposed wood beams, and a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace anchoring the great room. Retractable folding glass doors open the living area completely to the covered lakeside porch, creating an effortless flow between interior and exterior spaces ideal for entertaining and enjoying the tranquil waterfront setting. Three fireplaces located in the great room, covered porch, and recreation room add ambiance throughout the home. Every detail was carefully curated, beginning with the custom front door crafted from reclaimed barn wood and continuing through the elegant 8-foot interior doors featuring Emtek oil-rubbed bronze hardware from the Hercules Collection. The gourmet kitchen showcases Bosch and Thermador appliances, while the baths feature Italian tile and marble, curbless showers, and illuminated mirrors with adjustable lighting controls. Designed for both luxury and convenience, the home offers laundry rooms on each level, European White Oak engineered hardwood flooring in a sophisticated Grey Mist finish, and a fully encapsulated crawl space with dehumidification. Modern lighting includes automatic closet lighting, illuminated stairways, landscape lighting, and power extending to both the driveway and private dock. The residence features 2x6 insulated exterior walls, spray foam attic insulation, and robust 400-amp electrical service. Additional highlights include dual-zone propane recirculating instant hot water systems, premium Grohe, Moen, and Kohler fixtures, six frost-free exterior hose bibs, and a cabana bath with convenient outdoor shower access from the lower-level recreation area. Comfort is assured by two Trane 18-SEER HVAC systems, Wi-Fi-enabled thermostats, humidification on the main level, and a Mitsubishi ductless system serving the studio space. Outside, the private dock offers access for boating and swimming, while the lakeside lawn provides the perfect backdrop for gatherings and recreation. A security system and whole-home water purification system complete this remarkable turnkey retreat where luxury, comfort, and timeless design come together on the shores of Lake Toxaway.

Listed by Kenneth McCall of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 1003359

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 5
• Acreage 0.61

Welcome to an extraordinary lakefront retreat on Lake Toxaway, thoughtfully designed by renowned architect Allen Brown and expertly crafted by John Holbrook. Set on a rare flat lot with easy access to a private dock, this home blends timeless mountain charm with relaxed lakeside living. Inside, the spacious floor plan features 4 bedrooms and 4.5 bathrooms, designed for both comfort and entertaining. The main-level primary suite is a true sanctuary, complete with exposed beams, dual walk-in closets, and a spa-like soaking tub. Upstairs, generously sized guest bedrooms provide plenty of space and privacy for family and visitors. At the heart of the home, the chef's kitchen is outfitted with a Viking range, abundant storage, and an open layout that flows seamlessly into the great room. A stunning masonry fireplace anchors the living space, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere year-round. Step outside to enjoy the expansive outdoor living area, where a second fireplace overlooks the lake - the perfect setting for quiet mornings, evening gatherings, and unforgettable memories by the water. Elegant shiplap detailing throughout the main level adds warmth and classic mountain character. Designed with both beauty and functionality in mind, the property also includes a two-car garage with a built-in workshop, additional covered storage for boats, bikes, or extra vehicles, and a large lower-level storage area ideal for kayaks, paddle boards, canoes, and all your lake gear. Offering exceptional craftsmanship, breathtaking surroundings, and the best of Lake Toxaway living, this remarkable waterfront home is a place to relax, reconnect, and enjoy every season by the lake. Membership to Lake Toxaway Country Club is based on availability and application.

Listed by Fulmer Freeman and Ross Hyett of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 1003228

• Residential
• Bedrooms 3
• Bathroom 2
• Acreage 0.46

Fully reimagined lakefront on Lake Toxaway. The sellers purchased this 1978 home in 2018 and completed a full architectural redesign and remodel in 2023, rebuilding it for how you actually live on the water. The result is 4,340 square feet of finished living space on 0.462 lakefront acres, with 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, and several bonus rooms that flex as guest quarters, office, or media space. A wall of windows in the living room frames the lake. Two stone fireplaces with new chimney flues anchor the home, a Vermont Castings woodstove on the main floor and a gas fireplace below. The kitchen is fully new with new appliances and fixtures. Every level features new flooring, all-new Andersen double-pane windows and doors, spray-foam insulation, extensive new plumbing, and a fully rewired electrical system with an automatic transfer switch for a generator on an HOA-approved site. Outside, 815 square feet of elevated decks and 290 square feet of covered porches extend the living space toward the water. New stone retaining walls, a rock walkway, and fresh landscaping lead to the restored boathouse with upper sitting area and a new dock. A new 350-square-foot garage adds an automatic door and EV charging outlet. New roof with 8" SIPs, new wood siding, new paved driveway with new stone wall, new septic and pump tank, 3-zone HVAC, and propane gas complete the rebuild. Lake Toxaway Country Club access available, opening eligibility for golf, tennis, dining, and the lake club. A rare lakefront rebuild on Lake Toxaway. Move in, launch the boat, and settle in.

Listed by Donald Collins of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Meadows Mountain Realty - CA

MLS Number 1002999

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 6
• Acreage 3.02

Within Lake Toxaway Estates, this three-level residence is a study in position, perspective, and permanence. Commanding panoramic views across Lake Toxaway and extending into layered long-range mountains, the home captures what so few properties can deliver. A true alignment of water, horizon, and privacy. This is the Highlands-Cashiers Plateau at its most compelling. The main level is designed with intention. Expansive living spaces unfold around a grand stone fireplace, creating a sense of scale while maintaining warmth and intimacy. A formal dining room sets the stage for elevated entertaining, while the kitchen is both functional and refined, opening seamlessly to a covered outdoor living area with its own stone fireplace. This is where mornings begin and evenings linger. A dedicated office on this level provides flexibility without compromise. An elevator connects all three levels, reinforcing the ease of living throughout the home. The upper level is anchored by a private primary suite positioned to fully engage the view. Both the bedroom and the bathroom are oriented toward the landscape, creating a retreat that is both calming and commanding. Three additional guest suites, each with an ensuite bathroom, offer comfort and separation for family and guests. A second office with custom-built ins provides a quiet, purposeful workspace for extended stays or full-time living. The lower level shifts to a more relaxed cadence. A spacious family room, fitness area, and additional bath create an environment designed for gathering, unwinding, and hosting without constraint. Direct access to the outdoor living areas ensures a seamless connection to the surrounding setting. Expansive stone terraces extend the living experience outdoors, offering multiple vantage points to take in the lake, the mountains, and the ever-changing light across the Plateau. From quiet mornings to sunset evenings, the setting is both composed and unforgettable. Located moments from the community clubhouse and enhanced by a new roof in 2025, the property reflects thoughtful stewardship and enduring value. This is not simply a home. It is a position within one of the Plateau's most established and sought-after communities, where view, design, and location converge with precision.

Listed by Jochen Lucke of Silver Creek Real Estate Group,Inc.

MLS Number 1003249

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 6
• Acreage 0.68

Set along the pristine shores of Lake Toxaway, this exceptional custom home offers a rare blend of luxury, comfort, and breathtaking natural beauty. Featuring 4 spacious bedrooms with 5 full baths and 1 half bath. The residence is thoughtfully designed to capture stunning lake views from nearly every angle. At the heart of the home, a grand great room showcases a striking stone wood-burning fireplace, soaring beamed cathedral ceilings, and a dramatic wall of windows that frame panoramic views of the water. The chef's kitchen is equally impressive, equipped with a Viking oven and range, multiple dishwashers, a generous island, and even a built-in pizza oven-perfect for entertaining family and guests. Designed for both relaxation and convenience, the home includes a private sauna, elevator access, and a whole-home generator for peace of mind. Outside, a circular drive provides easy access, while expansive lakeside porches invite you to unwind and take in the serene surroundings. The property's extensive docking and boathouse, connected by a paved cart path from the home, make enjoying lake life effortless. Ideally located across lake from the Club, golf course, and marina, this residence offers the ultimate Lake Toxaway lifestyle-where refined living meets the tranquility of the mountains.

Listed by Kenneth McCall of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 1003250

• Land
• Acreage 2.64
• Subdivision Lake Toxaway Estates

This exceptional Lake Toxaway property offers a rare opportunity to own a versatile and scenic homesite in one of Western North Carolina's most sought-after communities. The offering includes a double lot totaling 1.278 acres, with the potential to divide, providing flexibility for future plans or investment. An additional parcel, Lot 50N, is also included, adding another 1.37 acres for expanded privacy or development options. The property is already thoughtfully improved with a driveway in place, along with a boathouse and docks-making it easy to start enjoying lake life right away. Positioned to capture both lake and mountain views, the setting delivers a perfect blend of natural beauty and tranquility. Conveniently located directly across the lake from the club, marina, golf course, and other premier Lake Toxaway amenities, this property combines privacy with easy access to recreation and social opportunities. Whether you're envisioning a private estate or multiple homesites, this unique offering provides the space, location, and features to bring your vision to life.

Listed by Kenneth McCall of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 1003327

• Residential
• Bedrooms 3
• Bathroom 6
• Acreage 0.74

Thoughtfully positioned along the coveted shores of Lake Toxaway, 90 West Shore Drive offers an exceptional blend of lakefront living, breathtaking views, and timeless mountain charm. Set on 0.74 acre with approximately 150 feet of shoreline, this remarkable property captures expansive main-channel lake views and includes direct lake access with a private dock and boathouse - perfectly designed for enjoying the very best of waterfront living. Crafted by renowned local builder Hub Powell, the home offers approximately 2,573 square feet of carefully designed living space that blends comfort, functionality, and classic mountain character. Expansive outdoor living areas create an inviting setting for entertaining, relaxing by the water, or enjoying unforgettable days on the lake. The lower level adds more than 1,000 square feet of heated bonus space with convenient access from the rear deck, offering exceptional flexibility for guests and recreation. Complete with a kitchenette, creative sleeping arrangements, and two full bathrooms, this versatile space is ideal for hosting family and friends, creating a private guest retreat, or expanding the home's entertaining capabilities. Ideally located within walking distance of the prestigious Lake Toxaway Country Club, residents enjoy convenient access to golf, tennis, dining, and pool amenities while embracing the privacy and serenity of one of Western North Carolina's most sought-after lake communities. Whether envisioned as a full-time residence or a legacy mountain retreat, this exceptional property presents a rare opportunity to experience the ultimate Lake Toxaway lifestyle. Membership to Lake Toxaway Country Club is based on application and availability.

Listed by David Guest of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 1003301

• Residential
• Bedrooms 3
• Bathroom 6
• Acreage 1.2

Positioned along the first ridge of Toxaway Mountain within the prestigious Lake Toxaway Estates, this extraordinary 5,000 sq ft mountain retreat blends timeless character with thoughtfully curated modern luxury. Once featured in Southern Accents as “a broad, low ramble of porches,” the fully renovated residence captures sweeping Blue Ridge Mountain views while offering exceptional privacy just minutes from Lake Toxaway Country Club and less than an hour from vibrant Asheville. Designed for both relaxed mountain living and effortless entertaining, the home features 3 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms, and a beautifully reimagined open floor plan where rustic elegance meets refined comfort. A chef's kitchen, spa-inspired baths, expansive gathering spaces, and thoughtfully designed interiors create a warm yet elevated atmosphere throughout. Multiple porches and patios embrace the surrounding mountain scenery, while a hidden children's bunk room and flexible recreation space add charm and versatility for hosting family and guests alike. Extensive improvements include a newly constructed 2-car garage with workshop, whole-house generator, UV water filtration system, EV wiring, and integrated smart home technology. Residents enjoy access to the exceptional lifestyle of Lake Toxaway, including scenic hiking trails, North Carolina's largest private lake, and optional membership opportunities at Lake Toxaway Country Club based on application and availability. A rare offering designed to be enjoyed for generations to come.

Listed by Judith Maureen Mitchell and Mish Nichols of Lake Toxaway Company

MLS Number 1003216

• Residential
• Bedrooms 4
• Bathroom 6
• Acreage 1.36

Some homes are impressive; others are unforgettable. Nestled within the highly sought after Lake Toxaway Estates, in the heart of the Blue Ridge Mountains-where the Land of Waterfalls meets refined luxury-this private sanctuary feels like a destination few will ever discover. Inspired by the charm of an English countryside lodge, the home blends old-world character with modern turnkey elegance featuring handcrafted details, rich natural textures, and spaces designed to feel warm, collected, and entirely one of a kind. Perched atop a private ridge, mornings begin above the clouds-with sweeping long-range mountain and lake views where breathtaking sunrises stretch for miles. Inside, every room tells a story-from soaring wood ceilings and a dramatic stone fireplace to a charming chef's kitchen, intimate gathering spaces, a statement wine feature, and a billiards lounge with wet bar. The main level is set up perfectly for entertaining and everyday living with rich oak hardwood floors, an office nook, formal dining room, and bedroom ensuite. The handsome gentlemen's retreat is sure to impress with a beautifully carved English wood bar. The floorplan easily offers the option to add an elevator allowing access to all three levels. The terrace level, featuring 10' ceilings, includes two additional bedroom ensuites, a second wood-burning fireplace, walk-in closets, and a home gym complete with another full bath and sauna. On the upper level, you'll discover the loft area with additional spectacular views and another private bedroom ensuite. The stone entry leads to an easy circular drive and two car garage with separate access to the large, finished living space above! And just when you think you've seen it all, the property continues to unfold-hidden outdoor spaces, wrap around decks on two levels, a gazebo suspended above the trees complete with a hot tub, moss-covered stone pathways, a tranquil waterfall, and a fire pit made for evenings that turn into memories. Completely private, yet moments from hiking trails and Lake Toxaway Country Club amenities including the country club, golf course, marina, and the Greystone Inn, this is more than a home, it is a legacy retreat. This property can include a transferable boat dock and available Glastron GXL 235 powerboat. Membership to Lake Toxaway Country Club is through application and availability.

Listed by Jeff Ramm and Mike Batchelder of Coldwell Banker Advantage